Article 6119 of news.announce.newgroups:
Path: paris.ics.uci.edu!csulb.edu!csus.edu!csusac!
      charnel.ecst.csuchico.edu!olivea!hookup!
      news.mathworks.com!uunet!bounce-back
From: rdippold@qualcomm.com (Ron "Asbestos" Dippold)
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,talk.origins,
            sci.astro,alt.fan.rush-limbaugh,talk.philosophy.misc,
            sci.skeptic,alt.sci.physics.new-theories,
            talk.philosophy.misc,talk.religion.misc
Subject: RESULT: talk.catastrophism moderated fails 205:301
Supersedes: 
Followup-To: news.groups
Date: 7 Mar 1995 16:18:41 -0500
Organization: Usenet Volunteer Votetakers
Lines: 617
Sender: tale@uunet.uu.net
Approved: tale@uunet.uu.net
Message-ID: 
References: 
             
            
NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net

				RESULT
	   moderated group talk.catastrophism fails 205:301

There were 205 YES votes and 301 NO votes, for a total of 506 valid votes.
There were 10 abstains and 6 invalid ballots.

For group passage, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES and NO)
votes.   There also must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO votes.

There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted.
Unless serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the group may
not be voted on again for six months.


Newsgroups line:
talk.catastrophism      Velikovsky/Saturn Hypothesis etc. (Moderated)

This vote is being conducted by a neutral third party.  For voting
questions only contact rdippold@qualcomm.com.  For questions about the
proposed group contact Ted Holden .


CHARTER

Talk.catastrophism will function as a medium for the exchange of
information and ideas amongst scholars actively persuing investigations
in the subject areas involved, including but certainly not limited to:

1. The nature of Venus and its intense heat.
2. The nature of antediluvian megafauna, their lifestyles,
   and the reasons for their development and extinction.
3. The various versions of a Saturn hypothesis, and their ramifications.
4. The great extinctions on Earth, and what brought them about.
5. Implications of catastrophism for the theory of evolution.
6. The nature of human communication and consciousness prior to the
   Flood and ensuing catastrophes.

The new group would also serve as a general vehicle for disseminating
information regarding these studies to the public at large.


Moderation Policy
_________________

[1]     A posting should be relevant to issues under discussion in the
        group.

[2]     Flames and abuse will not be allowed in any form.

[3]     A posting which ofrfers no new content to discussion already underway
        will be rejected.

[4]     The moderator will reject or accept submissions en toto, i.e. no
        editing of content.  Rejections should include a brief explanation
        for the reason for rejection, time and volume of postings permitting.

[5]     The moderator will not pass judgement on the soundness or correctness
        of submissions.

[6]     The moderator, in his role as moderator, will be impartial.

Proposed Moderator:  Ev Cochrane 


Rationale:

The closest thing in the normal usenet hierarchy to a group for this sort
of discussion has always been talk.origins.  Talk.origins, however, is a
known quantity on the internet, and many if not most of the people whom
we would like to have contribute to the discussions would simply not be
willing to deal with talk.origins.  Moreover, the basic charter of
talk.origins is for discussion of the creation/evolution debate, and not
the controversy surrounding catastrophism/uniformity.


talk.catastrophism Final Vote Ack

Voted Yes
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
0004200716@mcimail.com                                                Don Webb
100435.1107@compuserve.com                                           Phil Carr
3mez1@jeff-lab.QueensU.CA                                      Zadow Matthew E
AA6214@UOKMVSA.BACKBONE.UOKNOR.EDU                                 Dan Barrett
aaronw@ocf.Berkeley.EDU                                         Aaron Williams
abeggs@peg.apc.org
ad283@rgfn.epcc.Edu                                            David J Greiner
AK@green.astrakhan.su                                          Alexey Kljushin
aku@ccmaillex.dri.mgh.com                                             Ku, Alan
akwa@indirect.com                                               Silentus Redna
al@squash.eai.com                                                   Alan Lynch
alavizad@sas.upenn.edu                                      Seyed A Alavizadeh
Alex@lavra.kiev.ua                                         Alexander Krutiakov
apandey@u.washington.edu                                       Anshuman Pandey
archer@frmug.fr.net                                             Vincent Archer
arcline@phoenix.Princeton.EDU                                     Austin Cline
ashton@netcom.com                                                         shub
ault@cs.albany.edu                                                    Jim Ault
ayoub@westmx.westmont.edu                                         George Ayoub
bauerle@crypt.erie.ge.com                                          Ron Bauerle
bcoleman@mindspring.com                                       Benjamin Coleman
bd90622@bingsuns.cc.binghamton.edu                           Miles J. Thompson
bd@psy.uq.oz.au                                                       Bob Dick
ben@orion.lasierra.edu                                             Ben Clausen
blattner@teleport.com                                            Paul Blattner
bludingt@westmont.edu                                           Burt Ludington
brianvdb@netcom.com                                       Brian Van Den Broeke
bs812@freenet.carleton.ca                                       Janet Malowany
canepa@mercury.interpath.net                  Joseph Canepa - Personal Account
capps@cts.com                                                    Carolyn Capps
cconway@freenet.scri.fsu.edu                                    Clayton Conway
charlesw@nvc.cc.ca.us                                        John Charlesworth
chuck@uow.edu.au                                                Chuck Harmison
clifford@uclink.berkeley.edu                              Daniel Paul Clifford
cls6@midway.uchicago.edu                                         Cory L. Scott
compania@ix.netcom.com                                          M. Emily Cragg
csfb1!craffert@uunet.uu.net                                     Colin Rafferty
CTHO461@ecy.wa.gov                                          Thompson, Craig E.
cwhanlon@yosemite.eai.com                                Christopher W. Hanlon
Cyronwode@aol.com
D.Rekemeyer@zds.com                                           Darryl Rekemeyer
dan@olson.win-uk.net                                                 Dan Olson
darren@zion.eai.com                                               Darren Knapp
David.Ducheyne@rug.ac.be                                        David Ducheyne
DavidN2910@aol.com
daviswh@mail.auburn.edu                                             Bill Davis
Dennis.Ford@EMSS.Com                                               Dennis Ford
dhhvan@acs.ucalgary.ca
dkossy@teleport.com                                                Donna Kossy
dlc@eng.tridom.com                                                 Don Collett
douglas.cox@canrem.com                                             Douglas Cox
dtalbott@netcom.com                                               Dave Talbott
dwashbur@nyx10.cs.du.edu                                        David Washburn
dwcojh@interaccess.com                                             Joe Hertvik
dweller@ramtops.demon.co.uk                                        Doug Weller
eaagaard@bbs.puc.edu                                              Earl Aagaard
EEMPCZ2@MVS.OAC.UCLA.EDU                                             Sam Brown
egnr76@castle.ed.ac.uk
elturn@Richmond.infi.net                                         Elaine Turner
ev@pi.eai.com                                                      Ev Cochrane
evelyn@topanga.eai.com                                            Evelyn Wells
expnews@netaxs.com
faithe@actcom.co.il                                        Faith Erickson-Gini
fawl@nvc.cc.ca.us                                                   Steve Fawl
Floyd_-_Meyer@cup.portal.com
fme1@fenix1.dol-esa.gov                              FELICIA MARGARET EBERLING
franklin@sequoia.sequoia.com                                          franklin
fromke@nvc.cc.ca.us                                                Curt Fromke
fs8@ukc.ac.uk
Gastlycrum@aol.com
gelder@teton.eai.com                                            Dirk VanGelder
gmurry@comp.uark.edu                                                Greg Murry
gnelson@falstaff.MAE.cwru.edu                                      Gabe Nelson
GREENWOO@macc.wisc.edu                                       Roberta Greenwood
gsteckly@clark.dgim.doc.ca                                        Gary Steckly
gthomson@gpu.srv.ualberta.ca                                      Greg Thomson
GUIN@OREGON.UOREGON.EDU
haas@crunch.usgmrl.ksu.edu                                            Sue Haas
halbeth@brictric.demon.co.uk                                       Hal Bethell
hdudley@encore.com                                              Hugh D. Dudley
Hel9@aol.com
herb@schlossberg.dgsys.com
herbert@greathan.apana.org.au                                       Herbert Xu
hh@hhdo.venture.net                                      Henning Holtschneider
holley@nvc.cc.ca.us                                               Cathy Holley
hudd1569@varney.idbsu.edu                              HUDDLESTON. WILFRED JR.
hunt@austin.metrowerks.com                                           Eric Hunt
jah@iexist.att.com
jausem03@ursa.Calvin.EDU                                           John Ausema
jcy@arl.mil                                                  Jonathan Yi (CSC)
jdalmand@news.doas.state.ga.us                                     J.D. Almand
jdmills@ucs.indiana.edu
jdrieman@nlnet.nf.ca                                              John Drieman
jeff@vortex.eai.com                                                  Jeff Trom
jeffh@ludwig.cc.uoregon.edu                                          Jeff Hite
Jim.Loucks@EBay.Sun.COM                                             Jim Loucks
JimRooker@aol.com
jjsin@hyowon.cc.pusan.ac.kr                                        Jongjeu Sin
johnbr@bnr.ca                                               john (j.) brothers
joseph.kaduc@canrem.com                                           Joseph Kaduc
jsapp@lonestar.jpl.utsa.edu                                       Joel A. Sapp
K.Reval@sussex.ac.uk                                               Kiran Reval
kae@cc.gatech.edu                                                 Andy Edmonds
katherin@juneau.eai.com                                       Katherine Lattie
kdf@tigerteam.org                                                  John Nieder
kennedy@phys.ufl.edu                                            Dallas Kennedy
kevin@vortex.eai.com                                               Kevin Teske
kjtruscott@ucdavis.edu                                           Kent Truscott
Kpatton@aol.com
laurag@ritz.mordor.com                                         Laura Gillespie
leby@nova.umuc.edu                                                   Lloyd Eby
lenb@mpd.tandem.com                                              Len Bucuvalas
leonid@synops.msk.su                                    Leonid E. Dolgoborodov
livesey@solntze.engr.sgi.com                                       Jon Livesey
llarrow@netcom.com                                                 Lynn Larrow
locklin@phyast.pitt.edu                                          Scott Locklin
marko@mcbsgi.bio.sunysb.edu                                         Marko Horb
marty@vortex.eai.com                                         Marty Vanderploeg
maryann@iastate.edu                                            Maryann W Lundy
matjanis@phoenix.Princeton.EDU                             Matthew Clark Janis
MAXWELL@FNALV.FNAL.GOV                               what does THIS button do?
MBAUSER@KENTVM.KENT.EDU                                         Michael Bauser
mccombtm@netcom.com                                         Todd Michel McComb
md11@tmphost.york.ac.uk                                    Marco de Innocentis
medved@access.digex.net                                             Ted Holden
meus0001@maroon.tc.umn.edu                                     William E Meuse
mhaynes@bgsuvax.bgsu.edu                                     Michael F. Haynes
mjb1@lehigh.edu                                                      Mike Behe
moloch@neosoft.com                                      A. Voelkel & R. Reilly
mrdirt@iastate.edu                                            Richard L Scharf
msimons@husc.harvard.edu                                          Marco Simons
muse@panix.com                                                        J Woulfe
Neil@uk.gdscorp.com                                                Neil Taylor
neyman@earthlink.net                                Roger and/or Leslie Neyman
nick@inferno.fc.hp.com                                          Nick Ingegneri
nick@lt.com                                               Dr. P. Nick Lawrence
nitrous@ccnet.com                                               Kristi Weyland
oberpriller@astro.mdhc.mdc.com
oncedead@ingress.com                                                  Oncedead
palo@netcom.com                                                     Gerry Palo
Paul.Bernhardt@m.cc.utah.edu                                    Paul Bernhardt
Paul.Ferroni@ab.com                                            C. Paul Ferroni
PaulaBell@aol.com
PBJames@ix.netcom.com                                              Peter James
petersen@risoe.dk                                              Thomas Petersen
philip@storcomp.demon.co.uk                                          Phil Hunt
philjohn@garnet.berkeley.edu                                   Phillip Johnson
PhishPhan9@aol.com
pischel@informatik.hu-berlin.de                                   Erik Pischel
pmcrump@facstaff.wisc.edu                                       Peter M. Crump
probert@cs.ucsb.edu                                               Dave Probert
prophit@netaxs.com
quentinj@perth.DIALix.oz.au                                      Quentin Jones
r.hageman@dosgg.nl                                                 Rob Hageman
radrayer@panix.com                                              Rebecca Drayer
randrews@cas.org                                                  Brad Andrews
rant@pipeline.com                                                Alfred Vitale
rb2@netcom.com                                               Ronald Barrett jr
rbrtbass@ix.netcom.com                                             Robert Bass
reavin@access.digex.net                                          Harris Reavin
Richard.M.Smith@jpl.nasa.gov
richard@milton.win-uk.net                                       Richard Milton
rickburt@cix.compulink.co.uk                                    Richard Burton
S1.WDM@ISUMVS.IASTATE.EDU                                        Walter Morris
sbank@gdstech.grumman.com                                           Steve Bank
sbradley@scic.intel.com                                        Seth J. Bradley
schulze@vega.lpl.arizona.edu                                      Dean Schulze
scyun@hyowon.cc.pusan.ac.kr                                       Seokchan Yun
searchnet.zec@channel1.com                                       Searchnet Zec
selly@zion.eai.com                                               Mike Sellberg
SHAWNSMITH@aol.com
singtech@teleport.com                           Singularity Technologies, Inc.
SJDudley@aol.com
sjoland@ix.netcom.com                                  Peter/Stephen Sjolander
sklein@cpcug.org                                                 Stanley Klein
slf8@po.CWRU.Edu                                              Stephanie L. Fox
spickrel@rmc.edu                                                Shawn Pickrell
srogina@ira.uka.de                                            Susanne Kaufmann
Steno@aol.com
stephanie.george@mro.mts                                      Stephanie George
STOWEJM@jccw22.cc.sunyjcc.edu
strates@WPI.EDU                                          Michael C Demagistris
t1m@gasco.com                                                     Tom Milligan
t20mgt1@corn.cso.niu.edu                                      Michael G Taylor
tedk@gamera.eng.hou.compaq.com                                     Ted Krueger
Ted_Steele@uow.edu.au                                               Ted Steele
tegtmeie@panix.com                                           John R. Tegtmeier
terryw@MO.NET                                                    Terry Wilhelm
tgm@netcom.com                                            Thomas G. McWilliams
think@netcom.com                                                   Paul Nanson
tje3@columbia.edu                                             Tammy Jo Eckhart
tolik@obluo.tomsk.su                                      Anatoly A. Orehovsky
TROSE3@UA1VM.UA.EDU                                                        tom
Tuscadero@aol.com
tz@zion.eai.com                                                      Tim Zwica
vcgeo005@huey.csun.edu                                         lorence collins
viskoc@edu.eur.nl                                                     l.viskoc
wednsday@tezcat.com                                                  Wednesday
wjremine@mmm.com                                                 Walter ReMine
woolsey@uclink.berkeley.edu                              David Michael Woolsey
wwj@uscbu.ih.att.com                                         William W Jenkins
XJERD01@st.vse.cz                                           Jerabek David (NH)
yadallee@DoctOr.ampr.ab.ca                               Dave Shariff Yadallee
ZEVCHEK#m#_DEAN@lims-a1.lerc.nasa.gov            Dean Zevchek 3-2719 or 3-5365
zwica@zion.eai.com                                                   Jim Zwica

Voted No
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A.KELLETT@csi.compuserve.com                                      Andy Kellett
achepak@interaccess.com                                           Pete Kimball
adpeters@sunflower.bio.indiana.edu                                 Andy Peters
adrianrc@astro.ocis.temple.edu                                Adrian Cybriwsky
afargnol@spd.dsccc.com                                             Al Fargnoli
ah08@solo.pipex.com                                               Gavin Turner
ahall@cs.uml.edu                                                   Andrew Hall
aharvey@boulder.nist.gov                                          Allan Harvey
alanf@shell.portal.com                                              A T Furman
alanrw@cs.man.ac.uk                                            Alan R Williams
alaric@harlech.demon.co.uk                                       Iain D. Bowen
alfa@werple.mira.net.au                                           Glenn Durden
andre@gollum.phys.laurentian.ca                                  Andre Roberge
andrewh@earlham.edu                                               Andrew Hagen
ant@nest.equinox.gen.nz
ao443@yfn.ysu.edu                                             Brennan T. Price
Arthur.Chance@Smallworld.co.uk                                   Arthur Chance
arwel@cartref.demon.co.uk                                          Arwel Parry
B.O.C.Munro@bnr.co.uk
b0017@nibh.go.jp                                             Maurizio MORABITO
bailey@hagar.ph.utexas.edu                                           Ed Bailey
bchugg@leland.Stanford.EDU                                 Barron Deland Chugg
bcoe@trumpet.aix.calpoly.edu                                   Brian Eirik Coe
bds@ipp-garching.mpg.de                         Bruce       Scott          TOK
bear@metronet.com                                   Chris Hughes aka Rod Swift
bengtl@maths.lth.se                                              Bengt Larsson
bgarwood@NRAO.EDU                                                  Bob Garwood
bill@clyde.as.utexas.edu                                   William H. Jefferys
billgr@cco.caltech.edu                                       Joseph G. Billock
biow@cs.UMD.EDU
bjv@herbison.com                                                 B.J. Herbison
booda@lynx.noo.navy.mil                                        Martin H. Booda
brad@raindogs.net                                                  Brad Murray
BRADENP@delphi.com
brandes@cts.com                     Brian Girard - Brandes Investment Partners
brian.henderson@ectech.com                                     Brian Henderson
bruce@ais.com
bsc@oui.com                                                  Bill Stewart-Cole
BSCHLESINGER@NSSDCA.GSFC.NASA.GOV                         Barry M. Schlesinger
bseymour@encore.com                                              Burch Seymour
buehler@space.mit.edu                                            Royce Buehler
burt+@CMU.EDU                                                   Burt N Holzman
bvickers@bossanova.ICS.UCI.EDU                                Brett J. Vickers
bwanga@cats.ucsc.edu                                               Tim Seufert
byrne@cc.gatech.edu                                                 Mike Byrne
cadesjar@calum.csclub.uwaterloo.ca                                   Chewbacca
carroll@cis.udel.edu                                       Mark C. Chu-Carroll
cbstone@phoenix.Princeton.EDU                       Christopher Bradford Stone
cclary@lonestar.jpl.utsa.edu                           Christopher E. Clary
champa@cs.uregina.ca                                            Joel Champagne
CHAMPAGN@ugw.utcc.utoronto.ca
chapman@ims.com                                                   Dave Chapman
CHEN190@cantva.canterbury.ac.nz                     Peter Metcalfe, CAPE Canty
choffman@dvcorp.com                                             Chris Hoffmann
chris@eso.mc.xerox.com                                Chris Heiny x73186 - SPO
christw@meaddata.com                                       Christopher C. Wood
clive@sco.COM                                               Clive D.W. Feather
clstampe@mailbox.syr.edu                                         Chris Stamper
cmawer@garnet.bmr.gov.au                                           Chris Mawer
cnedin@geology.adelaide.edu.au                                     Chris Nedin
cnewport@netix.demon.co.uk                                       Chris Newport
cohn@MIT.EDU                                                      Henry L Cohn
colvard@esvax.dnet.dupont.com                                     Todd Colvard
CREED@UOFT02.UTOLEDO.EDU                                            Carol Reed
cro6e@kelvin.seas.virginia.edu                                   Charles Odell
cs94nca@brunel.ac.uk                                                       Nix
cward@Think.COM                                               Christopher Ward
D.Korycansky@qmw.ac.uk                                     Donald G Korycansky
d.wark1@physics.oxford.ac.uk                                           D. Wark
dale.m.skiba@medtronic.com                                       Dale M. Skiba
daniel@ldgo.columbia.edu                                      Daniel Quoidbach
daq@hpesdaq.fc.hp.com                                          Doug Quarnstrom
dave@tso4a.can.cdc.com                                               Dave Weil
david.harden@tfd.iglou.com                                        David Harden
david@aruba.ccit.arizona.edu                                             David
david@election.demon.co.uk                                     David Boothroyd
david_gonda@quickmail.cis.yale.edu                                 David Gonda
dboucher@selu.edu
dc5m+@andrew.cmu.edu                                          Daniel R Cormier
dc@panix.com                                                 David W. Crawford
dcook@utpapa.ph.utexas.edu                                       David M. Cook
dennisb@test490.pac.sc.ti.com                                     Dennis Burke
desj@ccr-p.ida.org                                            David desJardins
dgifford@aruba.ccit.arizona.edu                                Donna H Gifford
dhalgren@netcom.com                     Dave Filippi: NO MODERATED TALK GROUPS
diamond@RT66.com                                               Russell Stewart
dmjones@theory.lcs.mit.edu                                      David M. Jones
dmosher@nyx10.cs.du.edu                                           David Mosher
donb@Rational.COM                                                   Don Baccus
doog@hawk.hcsc.com
dorman@PARK.BU.EDU                                                Clark Dorman
DREITMAN@OREGON.UOREGON.EDU                  Daniel R. Reitman, Attorney to Be
dsr@lns598.lns.cornell.edu                                           Dan Riley
dtw@brooktrout.com                                              David T. Wolff
ducharmj@ERE.UMontreal.CA                               Ducharme Jean-Francois
duncan@engr.mun.ca                                                      Duncan
E51SHOOK@sask.usask.ca                                             KEVIN SHOOK
e89dh@efd.lth.se                                                David Hultgren
eab@msc.edu                                                     Edward Bertsch
emma@Kanpai.Stanford.EDU                                            Emma Pease
erg@america.net                                                 Eric R. Greene
Eric_Remy.XRCC@xerox.com
estin@psych.lsa.umich.edu                                           Paul Estin
ethan@grendel.as.utexas.edu                                     Ethan Vishniac
ethan@gso.SAIC.COM                                                 Ethan Brown
eyoung@cisco.com                                                 Eric Youngman
fekete@bcuxs2.bc.edu                      Zoli Fekete, keeper of hungarian-faq
France@Castor.physics.yale.edu                                    Ralph France
fritz@onyx.East.Sun.COM                   Steve Fritzinger - SE Sun Vienna Va.
Geoff.Arnold@East.Sun.COM     Geoff Arnold @ Sun BOS - R.H. coast near the top
George.Kambic@cle.ab.com                                         george kambic
ggw@cds.duke.edu                                                 Greg Woodbury
gill@mala.bc.ca                            Dr. Arnold G. Gill - astrophysician
gmd@cypress.com                                                  Michael Doyle
gnewman@iglou.com                                          Greg  'Bonz' Newman
goedde@jeeves.esam.nwu.edu                                        Chris Goedde
GPARKER@UOFT02.UTOLEDO.EDU
grn@alcove.apana.org.au                                        Geoffrey Newman
gsh@libra.usno.navy.mil                                       Gregory Hennessy
gsmith@math.utoledo.edu                                        Gene Ward Smith
gunnj@CERCA.UMontreal.CA
gwilson@sysubmc.bmc.com                                            Glen Wilson
harhan@cs.ucsb.edu                                           Hans J. Haraldsen
HARVEY@INDYVAX.IUPUI.EDU                                          James Harvey
HATCHER@CHIP.PA.MSU.EDU                           dyslexics of the world untie
hayter@ultryx.com                                                   Jim Hayter
hhowatt@cello.gina.calstate.edu                                H. Brent Howatt
hines@cgl.ucsf.EDU
hlgma@chevron.com
ingria@bbn.com                                                      Bob Ingria
irwin@stat.mps.ohio-state.edu                                    Mark E. Irwin
isaak@orient.aurora.com                                             Mark Isaak
jac@ds8.scri.fsu.edu                                                  Jim Carr
JAMES@DVORAK.BIOSCI.ARIZONA.EDU
james@jfs2.ne.uiuc.edu
jamie@moncomm.clark.net                                         Jamie Schrumpf
janda@netcom.com                         Keith "Justified And Ancient" Cochran
jbates@encore.com                                                   John Bates
jeff@owlnet.rice.edu                                       Jeffrey David Smith
jesup@scala.scala.com                                            Randell Jesup
JFCOST00@UKCC.UKY.EDU                                               Dan Phelps
jfurr@acpub.duke.edu                                              Joel K. Furr
jfw@jfwhome.funhouse.com                                         John F. Woods
Jim.Van.Nuland@pctie.microbbs.us.com                            Jim Van Nuland
jimf@vangelis.ncrmicro.ncr.com                                       Jim Foley
jimj@eecs.umich.edu                                                 Jim Jewett
jjh@3do.com                                                         Joel Hanes
jkj@habu.fc.hp.com                                                 Jim Jackson
jmeritt@smtpinet.aspensys.com                                      Meritt, Jim
John.Hughes@anu.edu.au                                           John P Hughes
john@jlc.net                                                       John Leslie
johnc@pele.sps.mot.com                                      John Carlos H3-296
johns@marcam.com                                              John Stomieroski
jonesm2@rpi.edu                                            Michael David Jones
joyce@wam.umd.edu                                                    Jim Joyce
jrehman@hydra.acs.uci.edu                                        Joshua Rehman
jrm@globalvillag.com                                     John R. MacWilliamson
jsk591@lulu.acns.nwu.edu
juedeman@shell.com
justinf@ugcs.caltech.edu                                           Justin Fang
jw63+@andrew.cmu.edu                                            James W Walden
Kal@UH.EDU                                                          Kal Marchi
karish@mindcraft.com                                              Chuck Karish
kary@possum.physics.ucsb.edu                                        David Kary
kcc@graceland.ih.att.com
kellogg@acpub.duke.edu                                           David Kellogg
kilroy@elvis.rowan.edu                                      Dr Nancy's Sweetie
konopka@cs.uregina.ca                                           Jeremy Konopka
krisna@cs.wisc.edu                                      Krishna Kunchithapadam
kurrel@tardis.ed.ac.uk                                            Steve Glover
kurtz@mustang.nrl.navy.mil                                           Bob Kurtz
labonnes@csc.albany.edu                                             S. LaBonne
lane@duphy4.drexel.edu                                            Charles Lane
LantzR@physio.wa.com                                             Lantz Rowland
larrys@io.com                                                      Larry Smith
lazio@astrosun.TN.CORNELL.EDU                               T. Joseph W. Lazio
lcasto@cis.ohio-state.edu                                      lawanna j casto
LGSites@aol.com
li@mailgwy.Data-IO.COM                                       Rostykus, Phyllis
lippard@PrimeNet.Com                                          James J. Lippard
lnh@physics.arizona.edu                                               Wombatty
loh@mtl.mit.edu                                        Vincent Kwok-Shiang Loh
lowry@lowry.eche.ualberta.ca                                       Brian Lowry
lrudolph@panix.com                                                 Lee Rudolph
macrae@pandora.geo.ucalgary.ca                                   Andrew MacRae
malik@paranoia.com                                                       Malik
manmak@athena.compulink.forthnet.gr                      Dimitrios Sfakianakis
matso@dtek.chalmers.se                                             Mats Olsson
mattk@comm.mot.com
mauricio@cs.columbia.edu                                    Mauricio Hernandez
maverick@CS.Berkeley.EDU                                        Vance Maverick
max@cypress.com                                                       Max Webb
mckelvey@fafnir.com                                          James W. McKelvey
mcuggy@craton.geol.BrockU.CA                                     Michael Cuggy
meb@piglet.portable.com                                              Mark Ball
metamatic!ediger@csn.net
mhagen@trumpet.aix.calpoly.edu            Michael John Hagen (michael j hagen)
milind@agni.cc.nd.edu                                            Milind Saraph
minhan@biomed.nus.sg                                               Tan Min-Han
mjones@gandalf.ca                                       Mike Jones ETC dept655
mlv@hsph.harvard.edu                                          Michael LaValley
mmbt@andrew.cmu.edu                                                  Mary Mark
mmc5+@andrew.cmu.edu                                              Mark Mattson
mmcon@netcom.com                                              Jon M. Gallagher
modemac@netcom.com                                                     Modemac
mooret@GAS.UUG.Arizona.EDU                                      Thomas L Moore
MORROW@FNALV.FNAL.GOV                                              Greg Morrow
mpatters@ednet1.osl.or.gov                                      Mike Patterson
mrstampe@mailbox.syr.edu                                   Marjorie R. Stamper
msaroff@moose.erie.net                                          Matthew Saroff
murray@snowhite.aes.mb.doe.ca                                    Murray Rennie
NARAHT@DRYCAS.CLUB.CC.CMU.EDU                                     Randy Finder
nareid@optsun.riken.go.jp                                         Helge Nareid
nathan@bwh.harvard.edu                                             Nathan Mehl
nsm14@cus.cam.ac.uk                                                  Nick Munn
paj@gec-mrc.co.uk                                                          paj
patl@eiffel.LCS.MIT.EDU                                    Patrick J. LoPresti
pcr@ic.net
peter.schill@zdv.uni-tuebingen.de                                 Peter Schill
philipla@microsoft.com
phillips@bright.uoregon.edu                                     Chris Phillips
PHILLIPS@stsci.edu                                         More pie, Man-goat?
PHYS266@cantva.canterbury.ac.nz
pim@nepac.ucsd.edu                                               Pim van Meurs
pjohnso@polaris.unm.edu                            Zoe Paddy Johnson CIRT CSOS
pkeck@bachman.ecology.uga.edu                                        Paul Keck
psrc@pegasus.att.com
ptbast@owl.WPI.EDU                                                Pete Bastien
qsi@cnh.wlink.nl                                                Peter Kocourek
quigley@iastate.edu
raphael@research.canon.oz.au                                    Andrew Raphael
raven@kaiwan.com                                                   Steve Price
RCote@gis.shl.com                                                    Rick Cote
remus@netcom.com                                                Remus Shepherd
rew@moontarz.nuance.com                                           Ryan Waldron
rgahan@houston.geoquest.slb.com                                      Ray Gahan
rhutchin@pilot.njin.net                                      Roland Hutchinson
rick@bcm.tmc.edu                                             Richard H. Miller
rick@TotSysSoft.com                                             Richard Jacoby
rittri@cs.chalmers.se                                            Mikael Rittri
RLPA80@email.sps.mot.com                                      John-Reed Maffeo
rnewman@media.mit.edu                                               Ron Newman
rodger@cadence.com                                               Rodger Hughes
rpacct@gothamcity.jsc.nasa.gov                              Robert G. Phillips
rrl@maxtek.com                                                 Richard R. Lynn
ruben@cco.caltech.edu                                       Ruben Krasnopolsky
rws3n@hydra.astro.virginia.edu                                Robert W. Spiker
s639823@aix2.uottawa.ca                               the Bitter Pirate LeSann
SAM@rc3a.mdc.com                                Scott Mankey .... 310-522-3897
samuel@cs.cornell.edu                                                Sam Weber
SANDY@VXW.UG.EDS.COM                     Wayne Sanders-Unrein 22-Jan-1995 1836
saroff@engr.dnet.ge.com                    MATTHEW G. SAROFF  03-Feb-1995 1516
scharle@lukasiewicz.cc.nd.edu                                          scharle
schinder@leprss.gsfc.nasa.gov                                 Paul J. Schinder
schumach@flare.convex.com                                Richard A. Schumacher
schwartz@galapagos.cse.psu.edu                                  Scott Schwartz
schweppe@acs.bu.edu
shaunc@faceplant.gvg.TEK.COM                                        The Grinch
shrdlu@earthlink.net
siefke@cig.mot.com                                                Steve Siefke
smarry@turing.toronto.edu                                         Smarasderagd
smm@hibridon.umd.edu                                          Steven M. Miller
smullins@ecn.purdue.edu                                        Scott H Mullins
solomon@vt.edu                                                  Larry C. Lyons
solovay@netcom.com                                              Andrew Solovay
sschaff@UNIXHUB.SLAC.STANFORD.EDU
ssolberg@morgan.ucs.mun.ca                                           s solberg
stainles@bga.com                                                  Dwight Brown
steinn@ast.cam.ac.uk                                         Steinn Sigurdsson
steve@ego.psych.mcgill.ca                                         Steve Hayduk
Steven_Hunter@macmail.lbl.gov                                    Steven Hunter
Steve_Mullins@vos.stratus.com
stimpy@marimba.raindogs.net                                            j. webb
stoodt@cis.umassd.edu                                           Michael Stoodt
stschulz@informatik.uni-kl.de                                   Stephan Schulz
sylvain@netcom.com                                            Nicholas Sylvain
tale@uunet.uu.net                                             David C Lawrence
ted@physics.Berkeley.EDU                                         Emory F. Bunn
terrys@gastro.apana.org.au                                         Terry Smith
thf2@midway.uchicago.edu                                             Ted Frank
Thomas_Galen_Ault@GS90.SP.CS.CMU.EDU
thursto1@husc.harvard.edu
timv@ccad.uiowa.edu                                          Timothy VanFosson
tomj@kibo.enet.dec.com                                          Tom Jaskiewicz
tomt@shasta.net.com                                                 Tom Tilley
trott@gandalf.rutgers.edu                                        Richard Trott
truesdel@nas.nasa.gov                                           Dave Truesdell
twalters@netcom.com                                                Tim Walters
ulli@donegal.ruhr.de                                     Ulrich Schulze Boeing
vince@groucho.ftest.gulfaero.com                              Larry D. Vincent
vpnet!vpnet!vagrant@quake.xnet.com
wbarwell@Starbase.NeoSoft.COM                                  William Barwell
weaver@ibm6.scri.fsu.edu                                          Steve Weaver
weemba@sagi.wistar.upenn.edu                                  Matthew P Wiener
welsberr@orca.tamu.edu                                      Wesley R. Elsberry
whl@wwa.com                                               William H. Leininger
wiegand@cig.mot.com                                             Robert Wiegand
wiley@wiley.b11.ingr.com                                            Dave Wiley
witkowsk@cshl.org                       J. A. Witkowski - Banbury Center, CSHL
wright@hi.com                                                     David Wright
xopamondo@shoreline.ca                                               Xopamondo

Abstained
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ataubb1@peabody.sct.ucarb.com                                 Thomas A. Upshaw
bertrand@ERE.UMontreal.CA                               Bertrand Jean-Francois
dominey@cbnews.att.com
greig@atlantis.Colorado.EDU                                   David Iain Greig
mmt@RedBrick.COM                                          M Mike Taksar KC6ZPS
otto@vaxb.acs.unt.edu                             M. "catastrophic voter" Otto
rparson@spot.Colorado.EDU                                        Robert Parson
rsgoheen@phoenix.Princeton.EDU                                Robert S. Goheen
rwpowell@arnold.Princeton.EDU                            Robert Whitney Powell
sws@dsc.com                                                        Shawn Smith


Votes in error
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
craig@kaibab.eai.com                                               Craig Weiss
   ! No vote statement in message
dickhuas@InforMNs.K12.mn.us                                    Dale Dickhuasen
   ! No vote statement in message
gothic@netaxs.com
   ! No vote statement in message
klikes@source.isd.state.in.us                                   Kevin T. Likes
   ! No vote statement in message
mdammann@estes.eai.com                                            Mark Dammann
   ! No vote statement in message
root@MIT.EDU                                                          Operator
   ! Invalid address